You mean an All Language Moderator. 
2 Likes
Oops! Thanks for correcting me 
1 Like
Yeah, I learned that slowly. But Iām begging you, do NOT take on a 50+ episode drama youāre not interested in. A lot of those projects take forever and if you arenāt even interested, itāll be really exhausting. Take shorter projects(max 30 episodes) if you donāt really like the plot. Korean dramas are nearly impossible to get into when youāre still a newbie, so you could try your luck with Chinese or other-region shows.
4 Likes
By the way, not all shows make use of a GE. Especially in movies, this part is often done by the CE.
On the other hand, some shows have more than one GE so that you can divide the workload.
4 Likes
Two of them do, and the other one is not looking for a GE.
3 Likes
Oops, yes. I just found out.
Columbia/Legacy
Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer
LP Title: A Childās Christmas
Released on: 1968-07-15
Associated Performer: Gene Autry with The Pinafores
Composer, Lyricist: Johnny Marks
ā Originally released 1949 Columbia Records
4 Likes
I really didnāt realise before that it was so competitive! I kept seeing mistakes in subtitles, and thought they must need more people to help. And obviously, itās all hard work, and there are many good subtitlers, editors, etc.; butā¦ if there are so many people filling the positions and waiting to - and it all being set out in this comprehensive structure for each show, with multiple checkpoints from different eyes - it makes me wonder why so many mistakes and awkward expressions still exist. Of course, if I keep going on the path of trying to get in and do get into a show, Iāll probably make or miss such things, too 
. Translation is a tricky process. But this is the reason for having all the layers, isnāt it?
I guess partly my point is that if there are so many of us wanting to help as editors, with all the needed skills, and there is this obvious need on so many showsā¦ can we not just be used? Even, if only, to touch things up from shows that have finished their editing, but somehow stuff was missed. It feels like such a roundabout process to find the right person who has the power to let you in and will do it, and figure out which shows have managers or moderators who will do this. Part of the problem is that those of us who donāt know another language sufficiently to do subtitles (translation) canāt get our experience in that way, and editors seem to be wanted who have lots of experience. So it seems like the only people who become editors are those who can translate, and āmove up the ranksā that way 
.
Ahh, new person rant 
.
Are there Chinese shows that have less than 40+ episodes? 
3 Likes
Time pressure might be part of the reason.
Thatās actually not true. We have some monolingual editors as well.
What you could do is let an experienced CE train you.
Yes, lots of them, especially the more modern shows.
4 Likes
I know it can be frustrating for newbies, but these roundabout methods developed precisely because there were irresponsible volunteers who did their jobs for the sake of quantity, not quality. There is and has been enough misuse of power all across the website.
One more thing:
The mistakes youāve been seeing in subtitlesā what dramas are those? Are they On-Air? There is a possibility that they havenāt been touched by the editors yet. The episode shows 100% subtitle completion when all the segments have been filled, not when all corrections have been made.
There are also some long, boring dramas with low viewership and low ratings, which makes the project progress at a snailās pace. Since source language translators are in high demand, they may work on multiple projects at the same time. Thus, the priority shifts to newer, more popular dramas, while the older ones drag on. Then the Domino Effect kicks in - if one volunteer delays, the entire chain of volunteers after him/her(including all the other language teams) gets delayed. Because these volunteers get delayed so much, they look for other projects. The popular projects usually have a deadline - one or two episodes are released per week. So the low-rated, not-very-popular dramas take the back seat. You could have a hundred editors on the show, but none of them can work if the TE or subtitler hasnāt worked on the episode.
Thereās a 47-episode drama Iām working on that is terribly boring. All the comments say it ends very badly(I refuse to watch it myself because I know I wonāt be able to stand working on the drama if I already know whatās going to happen). The ratings and plotlines are a mess. It finished airing in June 2021, but we reached the halfway mark only about a month ago. So anyone who watches past that mark will be watching either corrected pre-subs or untouched pre-subs.
The CM/Mods usually update everyone about the subtitling progress in the Channel page - the page under the Subtitle Team.
2 Likes
Good news!
Thereās a C-Drama that will be recruiting its team.
You can contact the CM, she is also works as an English editor.
Hurry up, the seats will be filled soon 
1 Like
Iāll tell you my personal opinion about this.
Reason 1.
Editors are not always good. They think they are, but they are not.
Why?
Their educational background, their speech habits, their age. How attentive they were at school, how good their school was, how do their peers speak, how educated was their family, how much they have read in their lives, how much they use internet chatrooms and fora, how deep their understanding of the culture of the original language ā¦ all play a role. Sometimes theyāre just lazy.
Way to fix this:
Thereās none. Since they donāt know thereās a problem, they wonāt do anything to fix it. If you tell them, you are the bad one and they resent you. They may leave the team with ruffled feathers.
Reason 2.
They sometimes let things slip.
Why?
Even the best editor is only human. Because they were tired, it was late at night. Because they wanted to finish quickly and then start dinner for the family. Because thereās no time or willingness (for an unpaid job) to go through episode three times. Because they are foreigners.
I consider myself a good editor with a good knowledge of English if I may say so myself, sensitive to things that donāt make sense or sound weird. Yet, at the end of the day, Iām not a native English speaker and there are some nuances (prepositions or a turn of phrase) that Korean subbers use and I donāt think of correcting.
How I compensate for that?
I create myself a safety net. A native English person either before me or after me. When Iām General Editor, I usually work with a native CE so the responsibility is hers, no problems. When Iām CE, I make sure the GE is native. And, for good measure, I often ask a Viki volunteer who is a professional editor in real life, to do post-release editing - that is, check again to catch anything I might have omitted. I go through each and every one of his corrections (after all, as CE, I have the ultimate responsibility): some of them I might not agree with, if they change a nuance of meaning. But I study them carefully and try to think of how I can make it so that he doesnāt have to correct that again in the future episodes. Yes, these instances are few. But if I can avoid them, why not?
Reason 3.
Brain auto-correct. There is this phenomenon that our brain tends to auto-correct small spelling mistakes and thinks itās reading the right thing. There are scientific experiments for that. You understand what you read, even with the misplaced or missing letter, and your brain automatically sees it as complete and correct. Quoting from a website:
Here is a brief sentence that has intentional misspellings. Can you read it?
Tihs is a smaple snetecne to tset yuor brianās abiltiy to corrcet mitskaes!
We bet you could read it, couldnāt you? See? Your brain helped you to read the sentence ā despite the misspellings!
So how does your brain do this? And how does it do it so easily? You didnāt even have to think about the misspellings and figure them out, did you? Your brain just did it automatically.
Scientists believe that the brainās ability to make sense out of misspelled words ā and to do so automatically and so quickly ā stems from the fact that most proficient readers donāt read words one letter at a time. Instead, most readers recognize entire words at once by seeing the first and last letters of the word and combining that information with other important information, such as the length, shape and content of the word.
So, as long as the first and last letters are correct and the other letters that make up the word are there ā and the mixed up letters are not many or not far apart ā our brains can make sense of them quickly. This allows us to read quickly and efficiently without getting slowed down or tripped up by misspellings.
Read more here
Now, this otherwise very useful function is not good at all for us editors! We have to willingly set it aside to find each and every spelling mistake. But some will undoubtedly slip. And sometimes they slip for two people!
How do I fix that?
I usually tell Other Language moderators that, if they see any spelling, punctuation or formatting mistakes, to please let me know in Team Discussions. And they do! There are some of them who are very helpful in that, and send me a list for each episode they finish editing. Thus thereās a whole bunch of other people as an extra safety net.
Of course I donāt know about other editors. What I told you is what I personally do.
7 Likes
Oh - I was looking at this one today - thanks!
Some on air, some not. Some 5 or 7 years old. I donāt watch the boring ones . I have high standards . Usually I watch ones that are rated over 9 (average).
Ah, this is good to know. Thanks! The rest of what you say makes sense.
3 Likes
Iām a victim of that sometimes, especially if Iām editing late in the night or after a tough day. I think the sentence is right, but something is still nagging me. So Iāll pass that segment and return after a while. I always spot the mistake after that.
Also, my native language is Greek, and the structure of sentences a lot of time is different from English. So by mistake, a couple of times I edited the subtitle keeping in mind the Greek syntax rather than the English one. Thankfully, Iāve managed to control it.
Thatās one of the problems bilingual or multilingual English editors have to face.
4 Likes
Still, those have to be finished one day and I see why some CEs rather proceed without, e.g., their TE if they finish one episode every 2 weeks. On the other hand, I can see that projects without a TE tend to have more mistakes (therefore, Iād rather remove the GE if anything - but the majority of GEs are rather fast).
Generally speaking, Iām curious how many issues there are given the fact that many GEs or CEs arenāt native speakers. However, the projects where Iām actually aware of the āweirdā English or mistakes are usually old projects. E.g., Iām currently translating a project from 2012 where itās very obvious that terms, sentences etc. make no sense in that context and there are tons of punctuation issues as well. However, I didnāt encounter such issues in recent projects, aside from some minor mistakes.
As CM you often donāt get as many applications for Editor positions (at least not for smaller projects). So, I donāt think that the chance is too bad if you can convince someone and react once the project is recruiting its team.
2 Likes
Doesnāt the Chief Editor recruit the English team, including the editors? Just as the Other Language mods recruit their team?
1 Like
Iāve seen different ways. There were series where the CE was the last one to join. However, I rather ask my CE as well, but I donāt think thatās always the case.
2 Likes
As a CE, I would hate it if the CM imposed a GE to work for me, as those two have to work very closely and share similar styles. But yes, of course, I know that sometimes itās done that way.
2 Likes
Yes, the GEs are pretty fast. For the project I was talking about, the GEs are given a three-day deadline, after which the CE takes over.
1 Like
It sounds like you are very conscientious. I agree with all your statements here, again 
. I also pick up nuances and I think this is what frustrates me when reading subtitles. Most of the time, theyāre great; often, theyāre almost perfect, but not quite. Sometimes, theyāre kind of awful.
Itās good that you create this āsafety netā, being aware of your own limitations. I think you have a very good system.
One of the reasons this convoluted process to get into editing subtitles here is so frustrating is that I am a native English speaker, I do speak/write well and have a very good handle on my language, I do have very good education, I havenāt grown up with text-speak, and I love that language and want it to be used fully and skillfully, for all that it offers. Sigh. This is life .
I really appreciate your insights. Thanks
2 Likes
On the page/article in the Viki Contributor Community that explains about the different positions and how to get them, it says to contact the Channel Manager about General Editor positions. It seems to all work quite differently from what these articles explain! Iāve been getting a lot of different and more correct information - about how it actually happens - here. In the future, Iāll try contacting the editors - although the teams tab doesnāt always show Chief Editor positions, just Moderators for the different languages, and Editors for the different languages. Itās hard to know, from that information, who to contact. I guess the Moderators?
1 Like